William Raveis Nantucket Owes $1.3M in Misrepresentation Suit

November 20, 2026 · 3 min read

Quick answer

A Massachusetts judge and jury ordered William Raveis Nantucket to pay $1,280,886 after finding an agent misrepresented that a home could be expanded. The firm is appealing, but the case shows how an unverified statement can lead to doubled damages.

A Massachusetts judge and jury ordered William Raveis Nantucket to pay nearly $1.3 million after a couple said an agent wrongly told them a Nantucket home could be expanded. Read: https://rltor.cm/dN2GrZ
Realtor.com (@realtordotcom) on X, November 19, 2026. View the original post

What happened

A Massachusetts judge and jury issued a $1,280,886 judgment against William Raveis Nantucket, according to Nantucket Current. They found that agent Melanie Gowen intentionally or recklessly misrepresented a material fact to buyers Mary Murray and Jeffrey Ment.

The couple bought a two-bedroom house at 151 Polpis Road in 2020. They have six children and say Gowen assured them the home could be doubled in size. Murray told the Current they did not fact-check Gowen because she said she had gone to the building department.

In early 2021 the couple contacted the town and learned that "absolutely not another inch or square foot can be added to the property," Murray told Realtor.com. A deed restriction and zoning rules blocked any expansion.

The couple sued in June 2021. The jury issued its verdict in January 2026, an amended judgment followed in June, and William Raveis and Gowen filed a notice of appeal in October. The Current reports the amount owed keeps accruing interest in the meantime.

William Raveis and Gowen deny wrongdoing. Their attorney said the buyers received the document that prevents expansion eleven days before closing and had two lawyers review it. He also said Ment testified that he does not believe Gowen ever lied to him. "There was no actionable misrepresentation and we feel confident that the Appeals Court will see things our way," the attorney said.

Nantucket Current retracted an earlier line saying the jury found Gowen had "lied." Neither the judge nor the jury made that finding.

Why it matters for agents

The size of the judgment comes largely from the Massachusetts Consumer Protection Act, known as 93A. The Current reports that a little over $867,000 of the total is doubled damages, with the rest covering attorneys' fees, interest and other expenses.

Under Chapter 93A, Section 9, a court can award two to three times actual damages if a violation was willful or knowing. The same applies if a refusal to grant relief after a written demand was made in bad faith. The statute also awards reasonable attorney's fees to a winning claimant.

The statute also gives a business a way to limit its exposure. A reasonable written settlement offer made within thirty days of the demand letter can cap recovery at the amount offered. According to Realtor.com, the couple's suit alleged the defendants failed to make a reasonable settlement offer after receiving a formal demand letter.

Three points stand out for agents:

  • Statements about what a property can become carry liability. The buyers say they relied on the claim that the house could be doubled.
  • Saying you verified something raises the stakes. The buyers say they trusted Gowen because she told them she had checked with the building department.
  • Documents in the file may not be a complete defense. The defense argued the buyers had the restriction in hand before closing, and the jury still found against the firm. The appeal will test that argument.

Murray put her view this way to the Current: "Realtors should read this and say, if I'm taking shortcuts, I shouldn't do that anymore."

FAQ

Why was William Raveis Nantucket ordered to pay $1.3 million?

According to Nantucket Current, a judge and jury found that agent Melanie Gowen intentionally or recklessly misrepresented a material fact by telling buyers a two-bedroom home at 151 Polpis Road could be expanded. A deed restriction and zoning rules prevented expansion. The judgment totals $1,280,886.

Is the William Raveis Nantucket judgment final?

No. William Raveis and Gowen filed a notice of appeal in October 2026 and deny any wrongdoing. Nantucket Current reports the amount owed continues to accrue interest during the appeal.

How does Massachusetts Chapter 93A increase damages against a real estate agent?

Under Chapter 93A, Section 9, a court can award two to three times actual damages if a violation was willful or knowing, or if relief was refused in bad faith after a written demand. It also awards reasonable attorney's fees. Nantucket Current reports a little over $867,000 of this judgment is doubled damages.

Sources

  1. Nantucket Real Estate Firm Ordered To Pay $1.3 Million in Lawsuit… (Nantucket Current, November 13, 2026)
  2. Nantucket Brokerage Must Pay $1.3 Million to Buyers Who Couldn’t Expand Their Home as Desired (realtor.com®, November 16, 2026)
  3. General Law - Part I, Title XV, Chapter 93A, Section 9 (malegislature.gov)